Four Core Democratic Values
“e pluribus unum”
Out of many, one. But what exactly constitutes the unique core values shared by all Americans? For without a mutual set of shared beliefs, any system of laws will inevitably be manipulated and distorted for narrow tribal gain-- a “parchment” constitution, cloaking our naked ambitions and basest instincts.
Core values underpin American exceptionalism, setting us apart from the other nations of the world.
A common value system ensures a united purpose in times of conflict, a mutual language for productive debate, and a faith in the future when reason is found wanting. Our actions, laws and personal views all must be tested across the core, and if found wanting, reimagined. If we cannot agree on the core, perhaps we are too big to govern ourselves….
So what is our one true civil religion?
There are no unique and perfect set of core values, but this choice of four is a good place to start. They were selected by listing over a hundred key social issues confronting this country, analyzing different value system justifications, removing those arguments of a purely moral or temporal nature, and then consolidating the remainder to a few key precepts.
There are no unique and perfect set of core values, but this choice of four is a good place to start. They were selected by listing over a hundred key social issues confronting this country, comparing different value system's justifications, removing those issues of a purely moral or temporal nature, and then reducing the remainder to a few key ideas.
These four shared values are easy to recall; powerful individually and insightful when combined. They are:
The Golden Rule
Freedom to Be
Responsibility for Others
Accountability for Actions
The Shared Democratic values logo (above) tries to capture all four doctrines in a single icon. You can click on any Core Value to discover more about its meaning. Each description illuminates potential solutions to many current challenges facing our democracy. Specific issues will be covered in our shared blog.
Shared Democratic Core Values apply to both individuals and to organizations - no government can operate by a different set of rules than those lived by its citizens every day.
A libertarian might be unhappy with a "responsibility for others"- conservatives might claim a"freedom to be" goes too far, and a liberal might insist a "responsibility for others" does not go far enough to protect us from ourselves. Which means these four core democratic values are just about right.
Core Values are Not Moral Judgments
Moral, ethical and behavioral rules are confusing similar- but that confusion can lead to bad decision and a dysfunctional democracy.
The differences matter.
For example, in the Ten Commandments the prohibition against murder and stealing have their basis in moral and shared democratic core values. But, worshiping a single god, or a commandment against "coveting" represent purely moral decisions (a person can covet as long as they do not steal; society has no right to intrude on their mental beliefs. Good, upstanding citizens can worship one god, many gods or no gods). In a pluralistic society, when rules based on moral imperatives are at odds with core values, they should almost always be optional for individuals to observe, and the government must adopt a neutral stance regarding those moral issues.
Such moral and religious issues include:
-
- Premarital sex
- Death Penalty
- Prostitution
- Flag Burning
- When human life begins
- and similar, important concerns
Only in extremely rare circumstances should moral decisions become the rule of law.
The moral nature of society emerges from the moral behavior of its citizens- not from regulation. The best way to influence others to adopt your moral views of the world as their own, is leading by example.
Strength is a Result of Tension.
All successful democratic systems are built on clear rules which at time are contradictory. Our constitutional federation is held together by three, often opposed branches of government- yet that tension forces everyone to sharpen their arguments and avoid responsibility for poor decisions. Dictatorships avoid disagreements by killing the dissenters- democracies welcome tension as a way to adapt their country to changing times. Without giving up its core value system.
Your freedom to travel ends at my property line. But, if you see me trying to murder another person in my front yard, your responsibility to others trumps my property rights, and you can rush in to help. My right to hold political or religious beliefs, no matter how distasteful and contrary to your own sense of morality, are mine and mine alone. I can publish those ideas, debate them in public, and raise my children in my image. But, if actions based on those beliefs cause damage to others, then I must take responsibility for rectifying that damage. If they cause my children to do damage to others, then others can step into the parental role to avoid further damage.
Only in this way only may balance be achieved.